Every creative has a version of the same fantasy.
You write the book.
Or finish the screenplay.
Or record the album.
And then—like magic—the world discovers it.
Readers fall in love. Audiences show up. The work spreads organically. Success arrives because the art is good enough.
It’s a comforting myth. It’s also one of the fastest ways to become a struggling artist.
In a recent interview with publishing strategist Ally Machate, we dug into what actually makes creative work succeed in the marketplace. After more than 25 years working in publishing—including time at Simon & Schuster and now helping authors launch books through her company, The WritersAlly—Machate has seen the same pattern repeat itself again and again.
The artists who thrive aren’t necessarily the most talented.
They’re the ones who learn how creativity and strategy work together.
Here are some of the biggest lessons creatives can take away if they want their work to support their life instead of draining it.
The Hard Truth: A Good Book Isn’t Enough
Most creatives assume that quality is the main barrier to success.
Write a great book and the market will reward you.
But publishing—like film, music, or any other creative industry—doesn’t work that way.
Machate explains that a great book is just the starting point. Publishers and audiences are looking for something else as well: marketability.
In other words, they’re asking a very practical question:
Who is going to buy this?
That might sound harsh to artists who prefer to focus on creative expression. But if your goal is to become a working creative, it’s a reality worth embracing early.
The market cares about things like:
- Your existing audience
- Whether readers are already interested in the topic or genre
- How easily the book can be positioned and sold
- Whether you have a platform that helps spread the word
This doesn’t mean art must be cynical or soulless. It simply means that once you decide to sell your work, you’re no longer creating in a vacuum.
You’re creating for people.
Platform: The Visibility Problem Creatives Ignore
One of the most misunderstood concepts in publishing is “platform.”
Many creatives hear that word and assume it means becoming a social media influencer—posting constantly, chasing algorithms, and building a massive following.
Machate pushes back on that assumption.
A platform simply means visibility.
It’s any way people can find you and your work.
That might include:
- A mailing list
- Relationships with other creators
- Media appearances or speaking opportunities
- An existing audience in your niche
- Previous publications or awards
Social media can be part of that, but it’s only one plank in the platform.
For creatives worried about time, this is a critical insight. Building an audience doesn’t require turning yourself into a content machine. It simply requires showing up consistently in places where your audience already exists.
Fiction vs. Nonfiction: Two Very Different Businesses
Another financial insight many creatives miss is that not all books serve the same purpose.
Machate describes two very different models.
Fiction: The Book Is the Product
For novelists, success typically means selling more books.
That means building an audience that grows over time—so each new release launches to more readers than the last.
The strategy is simple but demanding:
Write books readers love.
Deliver them consistently.
Keep your audience coming back.
Nonfiction: The Book Can Be a Tool
For business owners or experts, the book often serves a completely different role.
It becomes a gateway product.
Instead of making money directly from book sales, the book introduces readers to:
- coaching programs
- consulting services
- speaking engagements
- courses or memberships
Machate gives a simple example.
Imagine selling 100 copies of a book and earning $5 per copy. That’s $500.
Now imagine giving away those same 100 books—and gaining just one $10,000 client as a result.
The math becomes very clear.
This is one of the most powerful ways creatives can escape the struggling artist trap: thinking about how their work fits into a larger ecosystem.
The Review Problem (and Why It Matters)
If you’ve ever browsed books online, you’ve probably noticed something interesting.
You almost never buy a book with three reviews.
Reviews function as social proof. They tell readers the book has been tested and enjoyed by others.
Machate says a practical goal for new authors is:
- 25 positive reviews as a bare minimum
- 50 reviews where algorithms start helping visibility
But getting reviews isn’t about begging friends and family.
It’s about distribution.
You need to get your book into enough readers’ hands that a percentage of them will naturally leave feedback.
Strategies include:
- launch teams of early readers
- book promotion sites that reach genre audiences
- mailing lists and communities
At the end of the day, reviews are a numbers game.
The more readers you reach, the more reviews will follow.
The Secret Creative Advantage: Formulas and Tropes
Many artists cringe when they hear words like formula or tropes.
They sound unoriginal.
But Machate argues that the most successful books actually rely on them.
Genres function because readers have expectations.
Romance readers expect:
- emotional tension
- relationship obstacles
- a happy ending
Mystery readers expect:
- clues
- rising suspense
- a satisfying reveal
When authors break these expectations, readers often feel cheated.
The key isn’t avoiding formulas.
The key is using them creatively.
Think of tropes as the frame of the house. Your unique voice, characters, and storytelling fill in everything else.
Readers don’t want something completely unfamiliar.
As the saying goes:
People want the same thing—just different.
The Most Important Mindset Shift
Perhaps the most important idea Machate shares is one many creatives resist.
Your book is not your baby.
Your book is a product.
That doesn’t diminish the creativity behind it. But it changes how you approach it.
Products require:
- understanding customers
- researching the market
- positioning and packaging
- strategic marketing
When creatives accept this shift, everything changes.
Instead of wondering why great work isn’t selling, they start asking better questions:
- Who is this for?
- What do they already love reading or watching?
- How does my work fit into that conversation?
That’s when creative careers start becoming sustainable.
The Final Lesson: You Can Do Anything—But Not Everything
At the end of the conversation, Machate shared a quote she keeps on a sticky note beside her computer:
“You can do anything, but not everything.”
For creatives, this advice might be the most financially important of all.
You could:
- write multiple genres
- post on every social platform
- chase every marketing tactic
- launch endless creative projects
But trying to do everything leads to burnout—and mediocre results.
Successful creatives narrow their focus.
They pick the right audience.
The right strategy.
The right creative lane.
And then they commit.
Because escaping the struggling artist trap isn’t about abandoning creativity.
It’s about giving your creativity the structure it needs to thrive.
When art and strategy work together, the result isn’t just better business.
It’s a creative life that actually lasts.
To learn more about how Ally can help you, visit: https://thewritersally.com/
Leave a Reply